Basics

Salt, Acid and Tasting as You Go

Recipes tell you to season to taste and then move on. Here is what that actually means, which dial to try first, and how to taste so the answer becomes obvious.

Seasoning is a habit, not a measurement

Most recipes say "season to taste" and leave it there, which is unhelpful if nobody ever showed you how. Seasoning is simply the practice of adjusting a dish as it cooks so that it tastes of itself, only more so. It is the one skill that improves everything else in this notebook, and it costs nothing to practise.

Food cooked in restaurants often tastes louder than food cooked at home, and the reason is rarely a secret ingredient. It is that somebody tasted the pan five times and corrected it five times.

The four dials

When a dish tastes flat, the fault is almost always one of four things. Learn to ask which, in this order.

  1. Salt. Not enough is the usual answer. Salt does not only make food salty; it makes the other flavours easier to notice.
  2. Acid. A squeeze of lemon or a splash of vinegar lifts anything that feels heavy or dull, especially rich and long-cooked dishes.
  3. Fat. A knob of butter, a spoonful of yoghurt or a thread of good oil carries flavour across the tongue and smooths rough edges.
  4. Savouriness. Soy sauce, miso, anchovy, hard cheese, tomato paste or mushrooms add the deep background note known as umami, one of the basic tastes.

Sweetness and chilli heat are useful too, but they are corrections rather than foundations. Reach for them last.

Salt early, then again at the end

Salt behaves differently depending on when it goes in. Added early, it has time to move into the food and to draw water out of vegetables and meat, so it changes texture as well as taste. Added at the end, it sits on the surface and reads as a sharper, brighter hit. Good cooking usually uses both: a little in the pot at the start of each stage, and a final adjustment once everything is together.

Salts also measure differently from one another. A spoonful of fine table salt holds noticeably more salt than the same spoonful of a flaky or coarse salt, simply because the crystals pack together more tightly. Rather than converting between types, pick one salt, keep it in an open bowl beside the hob, and get to know your own pinch.

How to taste properly

  1. Taste from a clean spoon, never the one you have been stirring with.
  2. Taste the part you will serve, not only the liquid around it. A soup's broth and its vegetables season at different rates.
  3. Add a little, stir, wait a moment, taste again. Flavour needs a few seconds to spread.
  4. If you cannot tell what is missing, put a spoonful into two saucers: salt one, add a drop of lemon to the other, and compare.

Season in layers

Season at each stage instead of once at the end. Salt the onions as they soften, the meat before it browns, the liquid as it goes in, and the finished dish on the plate. Each layer seasons a different component, so the result tastes whole rather than tasting like an unseasoned dish with salt scattered over it.

Timing matters for aromatics in the same way. Dried herbs and whole spices want heat and time, so they belong early, bloomed in the fat before the liquid arrives. Delicate fresh herbs, citrus zest and ground black pepper lose their aroma to long cooking, so add them near the end or at the table.

When you have gone too far

Over-salting is not always fixable, but it is usually improvable. Add bulk and unsalted liquid: more water or unsalted stock, plus potato, rice, beans or tinned tomatoes. Balance with acid and a little fat, and serve something plain alongside. The old trick of dropping in a raw potato to absorb salt does not really work; what works is dilution.

The habit that avoids the problem is deliberately under-salting at each stage, because you can always add and you can almost never take away. The same goes for chilli and for anything strongly perfumed.

Keep the dials within reach

Seasoning well is far easier when the means to do it is at arm's length before the heat goes on, which is the practical argument for mise en place. Salt, a pepper grinder, a lemon and a bottle of vinegar belong beside the hob, not in a cupboard on the other side of the kitchen. Most of seasoning is really just the willingness to taste and correct, and that willingness collapses the moment it means walking three steps.

Learning your own preference

There is no correct level of seasoning, only the level that suits the people eating. Cook the same simple dish, a tomato sauce or a lentil soup, several times in a month and pay attention to the point at which it stops improving. After a few rounds you stop measuring and start recognising, which is the whole trick.

Next time something you cook tastes fine but boring, do not add another ingredient. Add a pinch of salt and a squeeze of lemon, taste, and decide after that.

Last cooked and checked 2026-11-22